Metal Snap Buttons vs. Jeans Buttons: What's the Difference and When to Use Each
By Madam Sew | Sewing Supplies & Tools Online – MadamSew | Published: 2026-09-08
Category: Comparisons
Learn the key differences between metal snap buttons and jeans buttons, their best uses, and how to choose the right fastener for your sewing projects.
Quick Answer
Metal snap buttons are best for garments and accessories that need frequent opening and closing, like jackets or bags, while jeans buttons are designed for heavy-duty closures on denim and workwear. Choose snap buttons for convenience and jeans buttons for durability and a classic look.
When you're sewing garments or accessories, the type of closure you choose can make or break the project. Two common options are metal snap buttons and jeans buttons. While both serve to fasten fabric, they have distinct designs, installation methods, and best-use cases.
Understanding the differences helps you pick the right fastener for your project, ensuring both function and style. This guide compares metal snap buttons and jeans buttons, so you can decide which one fits your needs.
Design and Functionality
Metal snap buttons consist of two interlocking discs that press together to close. They are typically used where you need a quick and easy closure, such as on shirts, jackets, or bags. Snap buttons allow for multiple open-and-close cycles without much effort, making them ideal for items you access frequently.
Jeans buttons, on the other hand, are a single-piece fastener that goes through the fabric and is secured with a separate tack or rivet. They are designed to withstand tension and heavy use, which is why they are the standard on denim jeans and workwear. Jeans buttons create a permanent closure that is not meant to be opened and closed often.
Installation and Tools
Installing metal snap buttons typically requires a snap fastener tool or pliers. The process involves setting the two parts of the snap onto the fabric, which can be done at home with the right equipment. It's a relatively quick process once you get the hang of it.
Jeans buttons require a hammer or a special setting tool to attach the button and tack securely. The installation is more permanent, and the button is not intended to be removed. This makes jeans buttons a better choice for projects where a strong, lasting closure is essential.
Durability and Maintenance
Metal snap buttons are generally durable, but they can wear out over time if the tension loosens. They are also more susceptible to bending if subjected to excessive force. However, they are easy to replace if needed.
Jeans buttons are built to last. They are made from heavy-duty metal and are designed to withstand the stress of daily wear and tear. Once installed, they rarely need maintenance and are very difficult to break.
Trade-Offs to Consider
- Ease of Use: Snap buttons are quicker to open and close, making them ideal for items like baby clothes or bags. Jeans buttons are not designed for frequent fastening. If convenience matters, choose snap buttons.
- Strength and Permanence: Jeans buttons offer superior strength and are meant to last the lifetime of the garment. Snap buttons may loosen over time. For heavy-duty use, jeans buttons are the safer choice.
- Installation Complexity: Snap buttons require a setting tool but are relatively simple to install. Jeans buttons need a hammer or press and are more permanent. If you want a removable fastener, snap buttons win.
Related Products from MadamSew
- Adjustable Zipper Foot - Perfect for Sewing Close to Raised Edges!: With the MadamSew Adjustable Zipper Foot, you will no longer have to worry about sewing into your zipper teeth when adding a zipper. Sew next to corded seams, tubular cording, slipcover welting and more with no problem! And, if your sewing machine won’t let you change needle positions, the Adjustable Zipper Foot will do this job for you! Adjustable slider (orange knob) allows you to change the position of your foot. When sewing denim or heavy fabrics, precise control is essential. This foot helps you sew close to raised edges, which is useful when attaching jeans buttons or topstitching around them.
- Bias Tape Makers - 4 sizes: 1/4" , 1/2", 3/4", 1": This set of 4 bias tape maker tools will fold both edges of your fabric to the center with great precision and low effort to create 1⁄4”, 1⁄2”, 3⁄4”, or 1” wide single-fold bias tape. Just cut fabric strips in your favorite color, grab your hot iron, pull the strip through the tool and press the folds for the bias tape. Fold in half, press and you have double fold bias tape. When adding snap buttons to garments, you often need neat, finished edges. Bias tape makers help you create clean bindings or plackets, giving a professional finish to your projects.
Choosing the Right Fastener
Best for
- Garments that need frequent opening, like children's clothing or cardigans
- Accessories such as bags, pouches, or wallets where ease of access is key
Not for
- Heavy-duty workwear or denim where a permanent, strong closure is required
- Projects where you want a classic jeans button look
Both metal snap buttons and jeans buttons have their place in sewing. Assess your project's needs for convenience, durability, and aesthetics. With the right fastener and tools, you'll achieve a functional and polished result.
